SOUNDSTAGE! ON HIFIMusic Archives

September 15, 2000

 

David Murray: Shakill's Warrior
(David Murray, tenor saxophone; Don Pullen, organ; Stanley Franks, guitar; Andrew Cyrille, drums. DIW/Columbia CK 48963. Kazunort Sugiyama, prod.; Jim Anderson, eng. ADD. TT: 72:56)

Musical Performance ****1/2
Recording Quality ****1/2
Overall Enjoyment ****1/2

I was going to write about Dave Alvin’s great new Public Domain: Songs From the Wild Land [Hightone HCD 8122] this time around, but I’m putting that off in order to discuss this 1991 release, which has been dropped by its label. It’s a fantastic sounding recording of exciting jazz music -- I’ve been using the disc as a reference recording for years. So why am I writing about it now? Well, I just discovered that amazon.com is carrying it as a $6.99 cutout. (Go to Amazon’s site, click Music and then click Bargain Music under Browse to find the cutout section.)

Cutouts are great! One of the ways I’ve always judged a record store has been by the size and quality of its cutout section. Big section + big selection = great store. Cutouts, by the way, are recordings (LPs, CDs, cassettes) that have been discontinued by their labels. Rather than scrap them, many companies mark them (in the LP era, a slit was cut into the album sleeve or a corner was cut off, hence the name -- these days, CD cases are drilled so that the UPC can’t be scanned) and sell them at a deep discount. At most stores -- amazon.com among them -- cutouts are guaranteed free from defects, just like regular discs, so they’re a great way to explore music you might not be willing to pay full price for. And while amazon.com doesn’t have the best cutout section I’ve ever seen, it does have some classics, like this David Murray outing.

Shakill’s Warrior is an organ quartet date -- the late Don Pullen and David Murray are the stars here, although Andrew Cyrille proves that his tuneful, skittering drumwork can complement any lineup. Guitarist Stanley Franks is relegated to rhythm duties, which he performs with great, if understated, flair.

David Murray, more than any other player I can think of, is the true heir to Sonny Rollins’ mantle as greatest living jazz improviser. I mean no disrespect to Rollins, who on a bad day is better than almost any other saxophonist at his best. But these days, a Rollins all-out, take-no-prisoners solo seems a rare event. Murray, every time out, is a force to be reckoned with.

His signature move is to seemingly play everything that can possibly be played on the tenor’s lower registers and then, just when another player would be running out of ideas, kick into the instrument’s squawking stratospheric upper ranges for an equally inventive foray. It sounds corny -- heck, it might even be corny, for all I know -- but it’s exciting in the way that sheer speed and physical mastery of a complex act are always thrilling.

Shakill’s Warrior isn’t Murray’s most exciting outing -- in fact, it has a pleasantly burbling almost mellowness that is quite appealing. Pullen wrote the lion’s share of the songs here and they’re blues-tinged, but essentially sunny, sophisticated fare. The musicians really cut loose only once on the disc and that’s the almost-eleven-minute-long "At the Café Central," which is a veritable torture-test for your hifi. For this ‘un, you’ll want to crank it up to eleven!

"At the Café Central" is a sort of funk fandango -- the kind of heavily electrified "Spanish" music that Chick Corea used to specialize in. It starts with a roaring statement of its theme, and then Murray takes off into a solo that scorches its way up from the tenor’s deepest registers. It’s a muscular solo, not far removed from a straight-ahead, gut-bucket, walk-the-bar R&B showpiece until Murray hits the end of the second chorus -- then, when most sax players would gently test the instrument’s highest tones, Murray rears back, bites into his mouthpiece and overblows a chorus of squeaks and squonks that shatter the tenor’s ceiling and send the melody spiraling towards the heavens.

And that’s when Pullen, having pulled the drawbars all the way back, romps in on a high-powered response that actually dimmed the lights in the Avalon/Spectral/MIT room when I played the piece at HI-FI’95 in Los Angeles. Murray then returns with yet another chorus -- much calmer, but still utilizing all the tenor’s range. Cyrille’s solo following it is a beautiful thing -- not to mention a system buster -- then everyone joins in a restatement of the theme and the song is over.

At eleven minutes, it has all the frenzy of a quickie -- and it will leave you just as drained and breathless.

There’s nothing else on Shakill’s Warrior that quite matches the energy and sense of limitless possibilities of "At The Café Central," but there aren’t many songs that can. That said, Pullen and Murray never disappoint and the entire disc is enjoyable and challenging. And the recording quality of the disc is extraordinary. Its dynamic range is remarkable, and it has a bright, biting, extended top-end that accurately reflects the harshness of a hard blown sax -- not to mention the wheezy rasp and full-throated roar of a Hammond B3/Leslie combo. And Pullen’s drums? So there it’s almost unreal how real they sound.

So don’t miss your chance to own this superb recording. Once they’re gone, you’re out of luck -- but for the moment, $6.99 plus shipping seems like one heck of a deal.

...Wes Phillips
wes@onhifi.com


SOUNDSTAGE! ON HIFIAll Contents Copyright © 2000
Schneider Publishing Inc., All Rights Reserved
Any reproduction of content on
this site without permission is strictly forbidden.