SOUNDSTAGE! ON HIFIMusic Archives

October 1, 2000

 

Dave Alvin: Public Domain - Songs From the Wild Land
(Hightone Records HCD 8122. Dave Alvin, prod.; Mark Linnett, eng.; Joe Gastwirt, mastering eng. DDD. TT: 61:10)

Musical Performance ****1/2
Recording Quality ****1/2
Overall Enjoyment ****1/2

Dave Alvin, lead guitarist for the Blasters and a student of all forms of American music, has released his own tribute to what Greil Marcus has dubbed "the old weird America" -- the strange, dark subconscious of the country as revealed through its folk songs.

Alvin writes in his liner notes, "Our folk songs live in the wild land of our heart. They aren’t relics from an idealized, sentimental past…. They’re hard, sad, rowdy, tender and joyous images of who we were, where we come from, who we’ve become and who we still are. A lot of what is good, and bad, about us is in these songs. They are in the public domain. They belong to nobody. They belong to all of us."

Alvin starts off with "Shenandoah," and that sad, haunting ballad announces right away what this recording is all about: fidelity. Gravel voiced and grave, he sings as if from a tomb, and his respect for the material borders on reverence -- but Alvin does not hesitate to make the song his own with his bold electric guitar arpeggios rising over ringing string band chords. His tasty guitar solo is a minimalist’s hymn to the landscape.

The song also announces the sonic pleasures that await within Public Domain -- this is a rock/folk album that sounds phenomenally lifelike. Alvin’s affection for folk is obviously not feigned -- it’s clear he loves these songs -- but he definitely approaches them with a rocker’s ear for dynamics and rhythm. Public Domain rocks! Make no mistake about that, but it is uncompressed and uncluttered. Instruments sound like the real things, whether they are acoustic fiddles or plugged-in Fenders. Electric bass and organ give Public Domain a surprisingly deep foundation too -- this ‘un will work those woofers good.

The band’s amazing -- virtuosic and comfortable with blues, bluegrass, or ballads, never shying away from rocking flat out with a solid backbeat or country breakdown. Rick Shea augments Alvin on electric and acoustic guitars and adds mandolin, pedal steel and background vocals. Bobby Lloyd Hicks on drums, Joe Terry on keyboards, accordion and harmonium, and Gregory Boaz on acoustic and electric bass complete the basic lineup -- but several other musicians add a extra lick or two on various tracks. If you get a chance to hear Alvin and the Guilty Men, you should jump at it, but if you can’t hear ‘em live, this record’s a pretty damn close substitute.

Alvin has chosen wisely from his source material. He wanders over a wide range of styles, from the mournful plaint of "Delia" to the rockabilly strut of "East Virginia Blues." And when confronted with a choice of versions -- as he was with virtually every song here -- Alvin seems drawn to the darker, quirkier interpretations. His "Railroad Bill" isn’t a loveable scamp or champion of the people (as he appears in some accounts); he’s a train-robber, nothing more. And I’m not sure there’s a cowboy song with less braggadocio than Alvin’s "Texas Rangers": "And when the day had ended and the Indians had fled/ we loaded up our rifles and counted up our dead/ … Sixteen of the bravest Rangers that had ever roamed the West/ Were buried by their comrades with arrows in their chests."

But the album’s not a bummer -- it’s a celebration. Alvin obviously loves this stuff -- he isn’t turning in a musicology project here, he’s having a ball. And so do we -- you just can’t help but grin when confronted with a band having such a great time. From start to finish, Public Domain is a joyful romp through America’s musical attic, and we’re lucky that Dave Alvin invited us to sample its treasures. Alvin’s love letter to the true American music is a howling success. If you have any interest in great music making, you owe it to yourself to get this record and listen to it often. It’s good for what ails ya.

...Wes Phillips
wes@onhifi.com


SOUNDSTAGE! ON HIFIAll Contents Copyright © 2000
Schneider Publishing Inc., All Rights Reserved
Any reproduction of content on
this site without permission is strictly forbidden.